Controversial Benefits of Microchip Implants for Alzheimer’s Wanderers (2024)

By Pamela D. Wilson, MS, BS/BA, CSA, NCG

Are the benefits of microchip implants for Alzheimer’s wanderers controversial?Microchip implants and GPS tracking devices are a solution for persons diagnosed with Alzheimer’s who wander and become at physical risk of harm or death.

A personal debate exists about safety versus personal privacy. Stories are in the news almost daily about an older adult who has wandered away from home. An aging adult, who wanders out of the home and is dressed improperly in hot or cold weather, suffers immediate health risks.

Even with increased awareness about Alzheimer’s disease, 50% of older adults over age 85 have dementia and are undiagnosed.

Alzheimer’s Wandering is a Significant Risk

For millions of families with a loved one diagnosed with Alzheimer’s Disease, the fear of wandering off during the day or night is a significant concern. We have all see stories of individuals diagnosed with Alzheimer’s walking out of their private homes or assisted living communities never to be found or found halfway across the country by the police.

The benefit of microchip implants for Alzheimer’s wanderers is safety. Wandering is a significant concern for retirement communities who accept individuals with memory loss, so much so that communities have devoted areas called memory care that is locked or gated so that individuals cannot leave.

Should individuals diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease who wander be “locked up” or allowed the freedom of living in society if a safe return can be guaranteed? While the benefits of a microchip for Alzheimer’s wanderers may be controversial, the microchip and GPS tracking device described below are options.

If you have a loved one diagnosed with Alzheimer’s or dementia and you are wondering about guardianship, you may find this online course How to Get Guardianship of a Parent helpful.

Micro Chip Implants Provide a Safe Return

Might an alternative, be a device that could provide medical information in the event of an individual becoming lost or hospitalized? VeriChip Corporation has developed microchip implant technology able to provide a medical history and identification for Alzheimer’s patients who wander, similar to the chip implants pet owners place in their dogs or cats. Interestingly enough the technology has other uses, for example, serving as a “unique lifetime identifier or ULI”. ⁽¹⁾

The chip has the capacity to hold the entire medical record of an individual. This information can is valuable in the event of a health emergency where the family is not immediately present. There are times when emergency care cannot be delayed.

Benefits of Microchip Implants for Alzheimer’s Wanderers

For example, in the event of an emergency room visit, the hospital can access immediate information often saving a life especially if the person is unconscious or has no one with them upon admission to provide a medical history. This would be especially relevant to older adults who live alone and who may not remember their medical history or be able to provide information about medications they are prescribed.

The Controversy of Microchip Implants for Humans

The controversy lies in discussions over government control, privacy, and security. Past records indicate that the chip has over 2,000 recipients and more than 900 medical facilities have chip readers.

One interesting concept is the idea of an insurance company having the ability to monitor the activity level of an individual, thus giving larger premium discounts to individuals who are more active. The cost is a $200 initial fee and a $10 data storage fee each month, comparable to the cost of a Project Lifesaver wrist band that is only good up to 1-2 miles from home.

Opponents to the concept state that a bracelet like Project Lifesaver or the Medic Alert Safe Return bracelet or necklace is less invasive and can equal the chip in results. But can it really? Either of these less invasive methods is limited by distance, 1-2 miles from home and medical information is not readily accessible.

Proponents state that the chip should be offered as a voluntary measure and then as popularity spreads be a mandatory item, especially for at-risk individuals and children. Leslie Jacobs, one of the first to receive a VeriChip said, “The world would be a safer place if authorities had a tamper-proof way of identifying people. I have nothing to hide, so I wouldn’t mind having the chip for verification. I already have an ID card, why not a chip?” ⁽²⁾

Advances in Microchip Implants to Alzheimer’s GPS Tracking Devices

Further advances have occurred in safety for individuals diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. GPS safety devices are now available.Tracking “soles” for shoes are now available so that if an individual wanders off the person can be easily located. As with microchip implants, GPS safety devices are controversial.

The question of do these devices invade the individual’s right to personal privacy arises in legal circles. One has to ask, would I rather have my loved one — or myself if diagnosed — be safe or have my privacy protected. That is a question that we have to answer individually and discuss with our families at the time memory loss is diagnosed.

Safety and Peace of Mind

Time will tell whether society will embrace microchip implants and GPS safety devices for humans or view it as a personal tracking mechanism for the government and large organizations. Yet undoubtedly there are benefits for those with memory loss who might become lost or are unable to report their medical history in the event of an emergency.

For More Information About Caring for Loved Ones With Dementia Listen to The Caring Generation Podcast: How to Talk to a Parent With Dementia

Sources:

(1) Michael, K. et al. Microchip Implants for Humans as Unique Identifiers: A Case Study on VeriChip. University of Wyoming, 2008. http://ro.uow.edu.au/infopapers/586.

(2) Michael, K. et al. The Social, Cultural, Religious and Ethical Implications of Automatic Identification. University of Wollongong, Australia.

Return to All Category Page