Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.
User profile for user: lukhanyo244
lukhanyo244 Author
User level: Level1 4 points
I understand that the location can be slightly inaccurate within a few meters radius. However, is it possible for the location to be more than 2-3kms inaccurate? Especially when the find my friends location is displayed as ‘live.’
iPhone 13 Pro, iOS 17
Posted on Feb 28, 2024 10:51 PM
Question marked as Best reply
User profile for user: SiliconSkipper
SiliconSkipper
User level: Level1 8 points
Posted on Feb 29, 2024 4:57 AM
The margin of error for location accuracy with recent iPhone devices can vary based on the technology being used, environmental conditions, and the specific location of the device.
I would classify a 2 to 3 km error as being unusual [1], but it's certainly not unheard of depending on the conditions and technologies being used.
The various location gathering methods that iPhone's use vary, typically using a combination of:
- GPS: In ideal conditions with a clear view of the sky and strong satellite signals, GPS-enabled devices can achieve high accuracy, typically within a few meters (4-10 meters). However, in urban areas with tall buildings or dense foliage, the margin of error may increase due to signal obstruction, resulting in accuracy ranging from 10 to 30 meters or more.
- Assisted GPS (A-GPS): A-GPS primarily provides better performance by compensating for weak GPS signals, so it would follow GPS in terms of accuracy.
- Wi-Fi Positioning System (WPS): WPS accuracy can vary depending on the density and accuracy of the Wi-Fi network database used by the device. In urban areas with extensive Wi-Fi coverage and accurate database information (think of areas that well covered on street view by Google Maps and Apple Maps), WPS can provide location accuracy within 10 to 50 meters. However, in rural or less densely populated areas with fewer Wi-Fi networks, accuracy may be lower.
- Cellular Tower Triangulation: Location estimation based on cellular tower signals typically has a higher margin of error compared to GPS or Wi-Fi positioning. Depending on the density of cellular towers and the accuracy of signal measurements, the margin of error can range from several hundred meters to a few kilometers.
[1] For additional information on GPS accuracy, the following site may be helpful: https://www.gps.gov/systems/gps/performance/accuracy/#how-accurate
If it's possible the person you're tracking has the wrong device selected, you'd need to take a look at Find My Friends app, there should be a 'Share My Location From' setting (I've never used this feature but the way it is described seems like it would have to be done from their phone rather than yours). But on a practical level, it should be fairly obvious when you're looking at a device that is always with the person, e.g. an iPhone as opposed to something that might only be with them on occasion, e.g. an iPad.
View in context
Similar questions
- Find my friends: location accuracyIf the blue/yellow circle is with a building, is there a possibility that they could be outside of that circle, in another building? That is, does it ever give the wrong approximation of their location? How accurate is the location of the circle? I understand that the purpose of the circle is to show that they are somewhere within that range, but is that range ever inaccurate? 22132
- Find my location on iPhone is a messFind my location is very strange and I have a few questions.a) is it normal for a location to randomly jump next door or to an apartment building across the street? If this was a daily occurrence, it would seem less weird, but this was an isolated incident. Happened randomly one day then never again. b) is it true that the smaller the blue dot, the more accurate the location? The dot seems to get very small when the person sharing their location with me (call it an employee) is “next door” or “across the street” at an apartment complex c) why is the blue dot separating from the “friend’s” actual picture? For example, it will show the the blue dot (with a white circle around it) across the street in a random apartment building, but the contact’s actual image/picture will be in the place they’re supposed to be? 8772
- Find My Friends - Erratic - Not Always ContinuousWhen tracking family members, Find My Friends should track their motion live (continuously). It often does and works well. But half the time it will not update continuously, only every so often, jumping from one position to the next.Normal? 3351
5 replies
Loading page content
Page content loaded
Question marked as Best reply
User profile for user: SiliconSkipper
SiliconSkipper
User level: Level1 8 points
Feb 29, 2024 4:57 AM in response to lukhanyo244
The margin of error for location accuracy with recent iPhone devices can vary based on the technology being used, environmental conditions, and the specific location of the device.
I would classify a 2 to 3 km error as being unusual [1], but it's certainly not unheard of depending on the conditions and technologies being used.
The various location gathering methods that iPhone's use vary, typically using a combination of:
- GPS: In ideal conditions with a clear view of the sky and strong satellite signals, GPS-enabled devices can achieve high accuracy, typically within a few meters (4-10 meters). However, in urban areas with tall buildings or dense foliage, the margin of error may increase due to signal obstruction, resulting in accuracy ranging from 10 to 30 meters or more.
- Assisted GPS (A-GPS): A-GPS primarily provides better performance by compensating for weak GPS signals, so it would follow GPS in terms of accuracy.
- Wi-Fi Positioning System (WPS): WPS accuracy can vary depending on the density and accuracy of the Wi-Fi network database used by the device. In urban areas with extensive Wi-Fi coverage and accurate database information (think of areas that well covered on street view by Google Maps and Apple Maps), WPS can provide location accuracy within 10 to 50 meters. However, in rural or less densely populated areas with fewer Wi-Fi networks, accuracy may be lower.
- Cellular Tower Triangulation: Location estimation based on cellular tower signals typically has a higher margin of error compared to GPS or Wi-Fi positioning. Depending on the density of cellular towers and the accuracy of signal measurements, the margin of error can range from several hundred meters to a few kilometers.
[1] For additional information on GPS accuracy, the following site may be helpful: https://www.gps.gov/systems/gps/performance/accuracy/#how-accurate
If it's possible the person you're tracking has the wrong device selected, you'd need to take a look at Find My Friends app, there should be a 'Share My Location From' setting (I've never used this feature but the way it is described seems like it would have to be done from their phone rather than yours). But on a practical level, it should be fairly obvious when you're looking at a device that is always with the person, e.g. an iPhone as opposed to something that might only be with them on occasion, e.g. an iPad.
Link
User profile for user: Chattanoogan
Chattanoogan
User level: Level7 24,522 points
Feb 29, 2024 5:06 AM in response to SiliconSkipper
Nice, concise treatment of the various geo-locating methods employed. 👍
Re: “… there should be a 'Share My Location From' setting (I've never used this feature but the way it is described seems like it would have to be done from their phone [or iPad] rather than yours) … “
Correct.
It’s specifically located in Settings -> AppleID -> FindMy -> My Location.
Link
User profile for user: Urquhart1244
Urquhart1244
Community+ 2024 User level: Level10 140,624 points
Feb 29, 2024 3:29 AM in response to lukhanyo244
For devices with cellular connectivity, it is about nearby connectable /supported cell towers. With just one, no triangulation is possible. A cell tower may often have a reach of 1–3 miles. Could that be it for that location?
Link
User profile for user: Chattanoogan
Chattanoogan
User level: Level7 24,522 points
Feb 29, 2024 4:45 AM in response to lukhanyo244
Another possibility:
Does your friend have multiple Apple mobile devices ? (e.g. an iPhone AND an iPad)
If so, your friend might NOT physically have THE device in his possession which is designated to report “HIS” position.
Which specific device is designated to report an “individual’s” position is a setting on your friend’s device(s).
The setting only appears when multiple “mobile” devices are on the same AppleID.
Link
User profile for user: lukhanyo244
lukhanyo244 Author
User level: Level1 4 points
Feb 29, 2024 4:33 AM in response to Urquhart1244
Thank you, and what about through a wifi connection? - is it possible to see the same inaccuracies?
Link
Find my friends location accuracy when saying live
