Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (2024)

Table of Contents

1. The Dough Is Too Sweet 2. The Temperature Of The Water Is Too High 3. The Yeast Is Too Old 4. The Environment Is Too Cold 5. You're Using Whole Grains 6. You Added Too Much Salt 7. You Used The Wrong Pan 8. Too Much Flour FAQs References

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (1)

Baking bread is only successful when you enjoy the entire process and most importantly, it comes out perfectly cooked, soft and fluffy. Although there are many bread recipes readily available to everyone, most don't tackle frequently asked questions about yeast.

Yeast can be a rather difficult ingredient because it only works best when it is used under certain conditions (temperature, humidity, etc). If your bread doesn't rise properly, check out the following common yeast mistakes and what to do instead:

1. The Dough Is Too Sweet

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (2)

A common misconception is that the higher the quantity of sugar in the dough, the better the rise. Contrary to that opinion, sweet dough won't rise properly unless you allow it to rest for a longer period than usual. That's because sugar absorbs the liquid in the dough, leaving very little for the yeast to feed on. Subsequently, the yeast dries out, becomes ineffective and the overall product comes out flat.

Here’s Why Your Sink Is Gurgling And How You Can Fix It ASAP

To avoid this: give sweet doughs enough time to rise properly or use a special type of yeast, the osmotolerant yeast which requires lower amounts of liquid, and so is the perfect fit for such doughs.

2. The Temperature Of The Water Is Too High

When proofing yeast, you must ensure that the temperature of the water isn't higher than 115ºF. If you don't already know, yeast are living organisms and at temperatures higher than that, they're killed off.

Note that the expert temperature recommendation for proofing is between 105 and 115ºF.

3. The Yeast Is Too Old

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (3)

It is an important rule that you check the expiry date of your ingredients when baking and that also applies to bread making. If the yeast you’re using is expired, chances are you will not get a good rise (if any at all) from it. Don't forget that yeast is a microorganism and does have a definite life span.

4. The Environment Is Too Cold

The best environment for baking bread is humid and warm, preventing the dough from running dry and allowing the yeast to work efficiently. But that doesn't mean that you shouldn't bake during winter!

If you find that your kitchen is too cold, you can crank up the thermostat while proofing your bread. Other easy solutions are to place the dough in an oven (make sure it is off!) and place a pan of boiling water in the oven along with it. The warmth and steam from the water provide the perfect conditions for proofing.

5. You're Using Whole Grains

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (4)

Nutritionists recommend sticking to whole grain breads for your health but they aren't very easy to do. White flour, the base for most bread, creates all gluten strands that give bread its airy texture. But, on the other hand, whole wheat and other alternative flours don't develop gluten as easily or at all, giving it little to no lift.

6. You Added Too Much Salt

Like sugar, salt kills yeast. Although you'll find a little bit of salt included in most bread recipes, adding too much of the ingredient can render the yeast ineffective. Therefore, always ensure that you measure correctly as stated in the recipe and avoid pouring yeast and salt directly over each other before mixing.

7. You Used The Wrong Pan

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It (5)

Using the correct pan size to bake bread isn't talked about enough despite its importance to getting the perfect rise. Most yeast bread recipes require an 8½” x 4½” pan which helps them achieve that great height and square size that’s perfect for sandwiches.

Always avoid using a 9″ x 5″ pan, commonly used for quick breads. If you bake your yeasted bread in this larger pan, the bread will still rise, but it will be wider and shorter giving the appearance that the bread didn't rise properly.

8. Too Much Flour

Another important rule when baking is to use correct amounts of the ingredients. If you add too much flour to the bread dough, it turns stiff and dry. Ultimately, the yeast also dries out, producing bread with poor (if any at all!) rise.

Tip: Invest in a good kitchen scale; you can never go wrong with your measurements with one!

Happy baking!

FAQs

Here’s Why Your Bread Came Out Flat And How To Fix It? ›

If the loaf has a flat top then you may have used flour which is too weak. Always use strong bread making flour. Other potential reasons for this problem could be that too little salt was used, the dough was too wet or that the dough was poorly shaped.

View Details ›

Why is my bread coming out flat? ›

Why did my bread not come out fluffy? ›

Do Not Over-Knead Your Dough. The over-kneading dough is a common bread making mistake, which makes gluten too tight for bread to rise, resulting in chewy bread instead of fluffy. Kneading correctly is most important to strengthen the gluten and give your bread a perfect texture.

Tell Me More ›

How do you salvage bread that didn't rise? ›

But almost as good as a proofing box is taking a Mason jar filled halfway up with water, microwaving it for two minutes, then putting your bowl of dough into the microwave with the jar to rise. The other thing you can do is place your lidded container or bowl of dough into a second, larger bowl of warm water.

Why did my dough deflate after rising? ›

When carbon dioxide exerts more pressure than a fully proofed dough can withstand, the cell membranes tear, releasing the gas and deflating the dough. An overproofed dough won't expand much during baking, and neither will an underproofed one.

Can I still use my dough if it didn't rise? ›

Fortunately, this is a problem that's relatively easy to diagnose and solve. If your bread dough doesn't rise, you can still use it and fix it by changing up the temperature or mixing in more yeast.