Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (2024)

Ad Feedback

By Lisa Drayer, CNN

5 minute read

Updated 8:01 AM EDT, Sat November 2, 2019

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (1)

According to the old rule of thumb, you're supposed to drink eight glasses of water per day (and some experts recommend even more). That can seem like a daunting task on some days, but here's the catch: You don't have to drink all that water. Roughly 20% of our daily H2O intake comes from solid foods, especially fruits and vegetables.

It's still important to drink plenty of water -- especially in the summertime -- but you can also quench your thirst with these 15 hugely hydrating foods, all of which are at least 90% water by weight.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (2)

Cucumber
Water content: 96.7%

This summer veggie -- which has the highest water content of any solid food -- is perfect in salads or sliced up and served with some hummus, says Keri Gans, author of "The Small Change Diet: 10 Steps to a Thinner and Healthier You" and a consultant to Mindbloom, a technology company that makes life-improvement apps.

Want to pump up cucumber's hydrating power even more? Try blending it with nonfat yogurt, mint and ice cubes to make cucumber soup.

Health.com: The best foods for every vitamin and mineral

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (3)

Iceberg lettuce
Water content: 95.6%

Iceberg lettuce tends to get a bad rap, nutrition-wise. Health experts often recommend shunning it in favor of darker greens like spinach or romaine lettuce, which contain higher amounts of fiber and nutrients such as folate and vitamin K.
It's a different story when it comes to water content, though: Crispy iceberg has the highest of any lettuce, followed by butterhead, green leaf and romaine varieties.
So when the temperature rises, pile iceberg onto sandwiches or use it as a bed for a healthy chicken salad. Even better: Ditch the tortillas and hamburger buns and use iceberg leaves as a wrap for tacos and burgers.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (4)

Celery
Water content: 95.4%

That urban legend about celery having negative calories isn't quite true, but it's pretty close. Like all foods that are high in water, celery has very few calories: just 6 calories per stalk. And its one-two punch of fiber and water helps fill you up and curb your appetite.

This lightweight veggie isn't short on nutrition, however. Celery contains folate and vitamins A, C and K. And thanks in part to its high water content, celery neutralizes stomach acid and is often recommended as a natural remedy for heartburn and acid reflux.

Health.com: 30 foods under 40 calories

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (5)

Radishes
Water content: 95.3%

These refreshing root vegetables should be a fixture in your spring and summer salads. They provide a burst of spicy-sweet flavor -- and color! -- in a small package, and more important, they're filled with antioxidants such as catechin (also found in green tea).

A crunchy texture also makes radishes a perfect addition to healthy summer coleslaw, with no mayo required. Slice them up with shredded cabbage and carrots, sliced snow peas, and chopped hazelnuts and parsley, and toss with poppy seeds, lemon juice, olive oil, salt and pepper.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (6)

Tomatoes
Water content: 94.5%

Sliced and diced tomatoes will always be a mainstay of salads, sauces and sandwiches, but don't forget about sweet cherry and grape varieties, which make an excellent hydrating snack, Gans says. "They're great to just pop in your mouth, maybe with some nuts or some low-sodium cheese," she says. "You get this great explosion of flavor when you bite into them."

Having friends over? Skewer grape tomatoes, basil leaves and small chunks of mozzarella on toothpicks for a quick and easy appetizer.

Health.com: 20 snacks that burn fat

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (7)

Green peppers
Water content: 93.9%

Bell peppers of all shades have a high water content, but green peppers lead the pack, just edging out the red and yellow varieties (which are about 92% water). And contrary to popular belief, green peppers contain just as many antioxidants as their slightly sweeter siblings.

Peppers are a great pre-dinner or late-night snack, Gans says. "We tell people to munch on veggies when they have a craving, but a lot of people get bored of carrots and celery pretty quickly," she says. "Peppers are great to slice up when you get home from work, while you're making or waiting for dinner."

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (8)

Cauliflower
Water content: 92.1%

Don't let cauliflower's pale complexion fool you: In addition to having lots of water, these unassuming florets are packed with vitamins and phytonutrients that have been shown to help lower cholesterol and fight cancer, including breast cancer. (A 2012 study of breast cancer patients by Vanderbilt University researchers found that eating cruciferous veggies like cauliflower was associated with a lower risk of dying from the disease or seeing a recurrence.)

"Break them up and add them to a salad for a satisfying crunch," Gans suggests. "You can even skip the croutons!"

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (9)

Watermelon
Water content: 91.5%

It's fairly obvious that watermelon is full of, well, water, but this juicy melon is also among the richest sources of lycopene, a cancer-fighting antioxidant found in red fruits and vegetables. In fact, watermelon contains more lycopene than raw tomatoes: about 12 milligrams per wedge, versus 3 milligrams per medium tomato.

Although this melon is plenty hydrating on its own, Gans loves to mix it with water in the summertime. "Keep a water pitcher in the fridge with watermelon cubes in the bottom," she says. "It's really refreshing and a great incentive to drink more water overall."

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (10)

Spinach
Water content: 91.4%

Iceberg lettuce may have a higher water content, but spinach is usually a better bet overall. Piling raw spinach leaves on your sandwich or salad provides nearly as much built-in hydration, with an added nutritional punch.

Spinach is rich in lutein, potassium, fiber and brain-boosting folate, and just one cup of raw leaves contains 15% of your daily intake of vitamin E, an important antioxidant for fighting off the damaging molecules known as free radicals.

Health.com: The 20 best foods for fiber

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (11)

Star fruit
Water content: 91.4%

This tropical fruit, also known as carambola, comes in sweet and tart varieties and has a juicy texture similar to pineapple. Its eye-catching shape looks great in a fruit salad or as an edible garnish on the rim of a summer co*cktail. As a bonus, it's rich in antioxidants, especially epicatechin, a heart-healthy compound also found in red wine, dark chocolate and green tea.

One note of caution: People with kidney problems should avoid star fruit because of its high levels of oxalic acid.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (12)

Strawberries
Water content: 91.0%

All berries are good foods for hydration, but juicy red strawberries are easily the best of the bunch. Raspberries and blueberries both hover around 85% water, and blackberries are only slightly better at 88.2%.

"I love strawberries blended in a smoothie or mixed with plain nonfat yogurt, another hydrating food," Gans says. Strawberries add natural sweetness to the yogurt, she adds, and the combo of carbohydrates, fiber and protein make a great post-workout recovery snack.

Health.com: 12 summer fruit and veggie recipes

Broccoli
Water content: 90.7%

Like its cousin cauliflower, raw broccoli adds a satisfying crunch to a salad. But its nutritional profile -- lots of fiber, potassium, vitamin A and vitamin C -- is slightly more impressive. What's more, broccoli is the only cruciferous vegetable (a category that contains cabbage and kale, in addition to cauliflower) with a significant amount of sulforaphane, a potent compound that boosts the body's protective enzymes and flushes out cancer-causing chemicals.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (14)

Grapefruit
Water content: 90.5%

This juicy, tangy citrus fruit can help lower cholesterol and shrink your waistline, research suggests. In one study, people who ate one grapefruit a day lowered their bad (LDL) cholesterol by 15.5% and their triglycerides by 27%. In another, eating half a grapefruit -- roughly 40 calories -- before each meal helped dieters lose about 3½ pounds over 12 weeks. Researchers say compounds in the fruit help fuel fat burn and stabilize blood sugar, therefore helping to reduce cravings.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (15)

Baby carrots
Water content: 90.4%

A carrot's a carrot, right? Not when it comes to water content. As it turns out, the baby-size carrots that have become a staple in supermarkets and lunchboxes contain more water than full-size carrots (which are merely 88.3% water).

The ready-to-eat convenience factor is hard to top, as well. Snack on them right out of the bag, dip them in hummus or guacamole, or -- for a bit of added crunch and bright orange color -- chop them up and add them to salads or salsas.

Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (16)

Cantaloupe
Water content: 90.2%

This succulent melon provides a big nutritional payoff for very few calories. One 6-ounce serving -- about one-quarter of a melon -- contains just 50 calories but delivers a full 100% of your recommended daily intake of vitamin A.
"I love cantaloupe as a dessert," Gans says. "If you've got a sweet tooth, it will definitely satisfy." Tired of plain old raw fruit? Blend cantaloupe with yogurt and freeze it into sherbet, or puree it with orange juice and mint to make a refreshing soup.

Foods that keep you hydrated

Story highlights

When soup is eaten before a meal, it helps you eat fewer calories the entire meal, studies show

Binding water into food slows down gastric emptying, keeping your stomach fuller for longer

CNN

When I first heard of “souping,” it brought me back to my clinical days working in a hospital, where pureed soups and other easy to digest foods – also known as “full liquids” – would be prescribed for patients recovering from gastrointestinal surgery, or those who had difficulty chewing or swallowing.

Then I reflected upon how much I regularly enjoy soup, especially for the comfort it provides on cold, dreary days – even though, thankfully, I have no health issues that would require such an easily digestible meal. Soup is often my go-to in the winter, especially varieties made with beans or skinless chicken, nutritious veggies, noodles and tasty broth. And I’ve always liked the fact that even though I feel full and satisfied after a bowl of broth, it’s not like the fullness I experience after eating a bowl of pasta.

Among nutritionists, I’m not alone in my feelings about this comforting, filling, yet not-so-high calorie food. “Soup can be a healthy and delicious way to create balance after a season of heavy meals or even a particularly indulgent weekend,” said Robin Foroutan, a registered dietitian and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. “It gives your digestive system a chance to reboot and de-bloat.”

chicken noodle soup Jupiterimages Related article Does chicken soup really help fight a cold?

Regularly eating soup might help you shed some unwanted pounds, too. Several studies have shown that when soup is eaten before a meal, it fills you up and helps you eat fewer calories for the entire meal. In one study, when people consumed soup for a snack instead of chips and pretzels, they lost 50% more weight – even though both the soup and snacks, as well as the total day’s diet, had the same amount of calories.

What’s the slimming secret of soup? Binding water into food slows down gastric emptying, keeping your stomach fuller for longer, according to Barbara Rolls, a professor of nutritional sciences at Pennsylvania State University who has authored studies on soup and its effects on satiety, and wrote “The Ultimate Volumetrics Diet.” Plus, she added, “the water in soup adds weight and volume so that you can have a satisfying amount without too many calories.”

The ‘souping’ trend

The weight loss benefits of soup have led to soup cleansing – a trend that has become increasingly popular over the last few years. In fact, according to Pinterest, “souping” is one of the top 10 food trends for 2018.

And unlike juicing, which removes fiber from fruit, soup can help to stabilize blood sugar for more sustained energy, especially when it includes tons of fiber-rich veggies, protein and healthy fat, according to Foroutan.

Mandatory Credit: Photo by Mito Images/REX/Shutterstock (8929716a)MODEL RELEASED Hands of woman taking picture of mocktail and saladVARIOUS Mito Images/REX/Shutterstock Related article How the 'Instagram diet' works

“Soups still contains the whole food, so fiber is still intact, but it’s easier to digest because it’s cooked,” said Foroutan. Juice is high in phytonutrients and antioxidants, but if it’s made from all fruit, it can be very high in sugars (even though they’re natural sugars), and this can cause one’s blood sugar to spike and drop, which can lead to feeling more tired overall, she explained.

Don’t know how to get started? Companies such as Splendid Spoon, Soupure and Los Angeles-serving Soupelina take the guesswork away by offering consumers various soup-based meal plans which can be delivered directly to your doorstep.

For example, a single souping cleanse day on Splendid Spoon includes five soups, such as beet balsamic bisque, fennel consommé, cauliflower coconut, butternut turmeric and red lentil dal. After the cleanse, you continue the week-long plan with the company’s breakfasts and lunches for five days, which include smoothies and bowls. Dinner is your choice. Day 7 is a “wander day” to enjoy eating as you typically would.

The convenience factor of soup delivery is a big draw for those with busy schedules.

Shutterstock Related article A New Year, new food resolution: Cook at home

“I choose my order, it comes delivered to my apartment and all I need to do is heat it up. I never have to worry about eating or having a bad meal,” said Morgan Hagney, who was in the throes of grad school and working full time when she started souping with Splendid Spoon about a year ago. “The recipes are delicious. They offer a variety of choices no matter the time of year, my mood or hunger level.”

Soupure offers soup only packages, like a three-day soup-only cleanse that includes kale minestrone and pumpkin miso, along with chicken or beef broth. But you can also get soups a la carte. “Many of our regulars have made souping part of their regular diet, and they cleanse on a regular basis or they simply incorporate soup into their regular everyday diet as a meal replacement,” said Soupure founder Vivienne Vella.

Customers of Soupure and Splendid Spoon say the programs have helped them maintain healthier, more nutritious diets, and lose weight, too.

Calorie check

Soup cleanses tend to have fewer calories than what you would eat on a typical day, which helps to explain how pounds may drop quickly for some. For example, calories for the cleanse day on Splendid Spoon range from 800 to 950, and breakfasts and lunches on the following five days contain approximately 300 calories per meal. On Soupure, cleanses range from 1,000 to 1,200 calories per day, depending on the type of cleanse you choose. Such a low amount could leave you irritable and hungry.

“It could be too low in calories for some people, but you can always add more to the soup or have an extra serving,” said Foroutan. “Plus, it’s the quality of the calories that count.” They key, she said, is to include a lot of vegetables, herbs and spices, along with protein such as lentils, beans or tofu for vegetarian options, or chicken, fish and bone broth for omnivores and flexitarians.

Follow CNN Health on Facebook and Twitter

  • See the latest news and share your comments with CNN Health on Facebook and Twitter.

      Foroutan said having only soup for a few days or only soup for dinner for a week is fine – she even does it herself – as long as you pay attention to your body and listen to its cues.

      She often finds herself souping periodically in the winter, from a variety of soups made in her kitchen.

      “I love homemade miso soup with bok choy, napa cabbage, seaweed and shiitake mushrooms; kale and white bean soup with turmeric, bay leaves, thyme, garlic, onion, crushed tomato, celery and carrots, which I sometimes top with organic spicy chicken sausage; my veggie ‘detox’ soup with kale, daikon radish, celery, bok choy, broccoli and turmeric; and even a simple broth with whichever vegetables are in my fridge simmered in organic bone broth. The options are endless.”

      Lisa Drayer is a nutritionist, an author and a CNN health and nutrition contributor.

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Ad Feedback

      Should you try ‘souping’? | CNN (2024)

      FAQs

      Does souping really work? ›

      What Experts Say. "The concept of eating soup to lose weight has spanned decades, but experts say an all-soup diet lacks nutrients and is not sustainable. They do agree it can be smart to eat vegetable-packed soups for some meals, though, as these are filling, nutrient-dense, and low in calories."

      Is it healthy to eat homemade soup every day? ›

      Great Source of Fruits and Vegetables

      Eating soup is a fantastic way to get more of these foods into your meals for a healthier and more well-rounded diet. Studies show that eating enough fruits and veggies can be highly advantageous for your overall health.

      Why does soup fill you up so much? ›

      Although liquids empty from the stomach faster than solids, thicker liquids like soup are different. They actually tend to cause the stomach to expand a bit more, and remain in the stomach longer, so you feel more full, for a longer length of time.

      Is soup easier to digest than solid food? ›

      “Soups still contains the whole food, so fiber is still intact, but it's easier to digest because it's cooked,” said Foroutan.

      What does souping do to your insides? ›

      Soup provides fibre and volume, hydration and a delivery system for foods which are typically easier to process than raw foods themselves. It is usually lower in sugar than juice – but watch out for salt levels. Souping can also assist with weight loss if done correctly.

      How much weight can you lose on a soup cleanse? ›

      Broth-based soup diets generally last for 7 days. However, some can last as long as 10–14 days. Over that time, proponents of a broth-based diet claim you can lose up to 10 or even 20 pounds (4.5 to 9 kg). On a broth-based soup diet, cream-based soups are restricted, as they're higher in calories and fat.

      What is the healthiest soup you can eat? ›

      6 delicious and healthy soups
      • Chicken Vietnamese Pho.
      • Green spring minestrone.
      • Herb and yoghurt-based soup.
      • Lamb shank and barley soup.
      • Pumpkin soup with star croutons.
      • Lentil and vegetable soup with crusty bread.
      Apr 26, 2020

      Does the 7 day soup diet work? ›

      The Cabbage Soup Diet is a short-term weight loss diet. Proponents of the diet say that it can help you lose up to 10 pounds (4.5 kg) in a single week, but many health experts warn that the diet does not promote health and wellness, and results are unsustainable.

      Will I lose weight if I only eat soup? ›

      As the soup diet usually only lasts for 7-14 days, it's not recommended in the long term. The NHS also highlights how very low-calorie diets like this often lead to short term weight loss, but it's likely that you'll put some or all of the weight back on once you go back to eating normally.

      Why am I heavier after eating soup? ›

      If you are trying to ​​cut back on big meals and you replace a meal with low-calorie soup, you might notice an increase in the scale—even though the weight is simply water retention.

      Does soup bloat your stomach? ›

      In addition, soup might make you extra bloated since it contains a lot of liquid, says Shapiro, giving you that overly full, distended feeling. “A great way to avoid this is to simply buy low-sodium varieties and to rinse any canned veggies or beans under running water before consuming,” she advises.

      Can too much soup be bad for you? ›

      Other types of soup you should watch out for are instant and canned soups, which are often loaded with sodium. High sodium intakes are associated with high blood pressure, a risk factor for heart and kidney disease, and stroke ( 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ).

      Is soup a sufficient meal? ›

      To rightly be considered as dinner, a soup must not only be filling, but must also be correct on the calorie chart. Hearty soups like Russian Borsch, Vietnamese pho, and Italian Minestrone are considered as main courses. They have an apt mix of vegetables, protein and carbohydrates in a single bowl.

      Why is soup good for you at night? ›

      Keeps You Satiated: Soup can help to keep you satiated, as it is a liquid-based meal that is typically high in water and fibre content. The water and fiber in soup can help to fill you up, making you feel less hungry. Additionally, soup is often low in calories, which can also help to keep you feeling full.

      How long does soup stay in your stomach? ›

      The bottom line. After you eat, food typically spends 2 to 4 hours in your stomach. However, this can vary based on the type of food you've eaten, how much, and other factors. Liquids usually leave your stomach quickly, while solid foods typically take longer.

      What happens if I only eat soup for a week? ›

      As the soup diet usually only lasts for 7-14 days, it's not recommended in the long term. The NHS also highlights how very low-calorie diets like this often lead to short term weight loss, but it's likely that you'll put some or all of the weight back on once you go back to eating normally.

      Is souping the key to weight loss? ›

      They found that people who ate two servings of soup a day as a snack lost 50 percent more weight than people who snacked on the same amount of calories in pretzels and chips. Soup eaters lost as much as 15 pounds over a year while the most weight a pretzel eater lost was 11.

      Does soup help lose belly fat? ›

      Yes, that's right — the soup diet really does work. Or at least the concept of a soup diet can yield legitimate weight loss. Research shows soup is a helpful weight-loss food: It has the potential to be as satisfying as eating solid food, even though it's a liquid, per an older paper in ‌Physiology & Behavior‌.

      How much weight can you lose on the 7 day cabbage soup diet? ›

      People who follow the diet strictly will likely lose some weight, potentially 10 pounds per week or more. This is because it involves eating so few calories each day. However, in most cases, people quickly regain this lost weight once they return to their regular diet.

      References

      Top Articles
      Thick Cut Hickory Smoked Premium Bacon
      The Story of Dave and His Killer Bread
      Barbara Roufs Measurements
      Msbs Bowling
      Buenasado Bluewater
      Boost Mobile 69Th Ashland
      Word trip Answers All Levels [2000+ in One Page Updated 2023] » Puzzle Game Master
      Understanding Pickleball Court Dimensions: Essential Guide
      Jeff Siegel Picks Santa Anita
      Ohio Lottery Full Site
      They Cloned Tyrone Showtimes Near Showbiz Cinemas - Kingwood
      Pokewilds Wiki
      Partyline Ads for Wednesday, September 11, 2024
      Hannaford Weekly Flyer Manchester Nh
      Alvin Isd Ixl
      Craiglist Tulsa Ok
      Chester Farmers Market vendor Daddy's a Hooker: Ed Lowery happy fiber artist for 65 years
      Bank Hours Saturday Chase
      Ilovekaylax
      How Much Is Cvs Sports Physical
      9:00 A.m. Cdt
      Craigslist North Platte Nebraska
      Who are Yasmin Le Bon Parents? Meet Iradj Parvaneh and Patricia Parvaneh
      Hannah Nichole Kast Twitter
      Tamilyogi. Vip
      Indian Restaurants In Cape Cod
      Mylaheychart Login
      Junior's Barber Shop & Co — Jupiter
      Eddie Messel Leaving 1011
      Erome.ccom
      Caliber Near Me
      Affordable Prom Dresses for Women | Fashion Nova
      Antique Wedding Favors
      ONE PAN BROCCOLI CASHEW CHICKEN
      Ms Eppi Login
      The Bold And The Beautiful Soap Hub
      Hewn New Bedford
      Any Ups Stores Open Today
      Star Wars Galaxy Of Heroes Forums
      Witchwood Icon
      Fade En V Pelo Corto
      Dimmitt Range Rover
      American Freight Mason Ohio
      Curaleaf Announces Majority Stake and Forms Strategic Partnership with Germany's Four 20 Pharma, a Fully EU-GMP & GDP Licensed Producer and Distributor of Medical Cannabis
      Lee County Buy Sell And Trade
      Every Act That's Auditioned for AGT Season 18 So Far
      Rubmd.com.louisville
      Infinity Pool Showtimes Near Maya Cinemas Bakersfield
      Minute Clinic Schedule 360
      Auctionzipauctions
      XY6020L 6-70V CNC einstellbares stabilisiertes Spannungsnetzteil Konstantspannung Konstantstrom 20A/1200W Buck-Modul Bewertungen
      Welcome to the Newest Members of the Lawrenceville School Faculty
      Latest Posts
      Article information

      Author: Dong Thiel

      Last Updated:

      Views: 5948

      Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

      Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

      Author information

      Name: Dong Thiel

      Birthday: 2001-07-14

      Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

      Phone: +3512198379449

      Job: Design Planner

      Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

      Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.